# Selling outside the limits with a manager's approval

Section: Selling. Address: https://vende.id/docs/jualan/ajukan-ke-atasan?lang=en

A cashier asks a manager to allow a note the shop's rules refuse, such as a price under cost, and the manager approves it from afar.

A cashier without a certain permission is normally refused when a note breaks a shop rule. With **Ask a manager**, the cashier does not need to call the manager to the till: the manager sees the note on their phone and approves it.

This is part of [Asking a manager for permission](https://vende.id/docs/pengaturan/minta-izin?lang=en), so the **Ask a manager** feature must be on for your shop. If it is not, the refusal names the people who may record that note instead.

## Rules that can be asked about

| Rule | Permission of the manager who decides |
| --- | --- |
| Price under the limit, including under cost | **Sell Below Cost** |
| Discount over the limit, including a note discount that takes a line discount past it | **Bypass Discount Limit** |
| Free item | **Bypass Discount Limit** |
| Return without an original note | **Return Without Note** |
| A note that takes the customer's receivable past the limit | **Bypass Credit Limit** |

When one note breaks several rules, one request covers all of them, and a manager who holds all those permissions decides.

## How the cashier asks

1. Save the note as usual. When one of the rules above refuses it, Vende gives the reason and shows the **Ask a manager** box. A reason about price never names the cost of the goods.
2. Write the **Reason**, for example "regular customer", then press **Send request**.
3. The managers who may decide get a notification on the bell. When their number is saved, a **Tell them on WhatsApp** button appears too.
4. Once approved, you get a notification. Save the same note again, without changing its lines, prices, discounts or customer.

The approval is only for the note with the lines and prices that were asked. If anything changes, it is a new note and must be asked again. An approval can be used once and runs for a short time, set by the shop in **Settings → Access Requests** (60 minutes by default).

Ask a manager is available on the Till, Quick Sale and Invoice Mode. On Invoice Mode a cashier can ask about a price under the limit, a discount over the limit and the credit limit; free-item lines and returns without a note on that screen are recorded by a manager who holds the permission, or asked from the Till. When Vende says the note breaks no rule a manager can approve, just save it; when something else refuses it, such as short stock, the reason is written on screen.

## How the manager decides

1. Open **Transactions → Access Requests**, the **Waiting** tab, or tap the notification on the bell.
2. Press **Approve**. The window that opens shows the customer, each line with its quantity, price, final price and cost (when you may see cost), the note discount, and the amount owed when it is about the credit limit.
3. Press **Approve**, or **Reject** with a reason so the cashier knows.

The cashier never sees the cost. Once the note is saved, its Activity History records who approved it and who the cashier was. See [Viewing the activity history](https://vende.id/docs/pengaturan/riwayat-aktivitas?lang=en).

## Cashier loss limit

For goods that may be sold a little under cost without approval each time, fill **Cashier Loss Limit** on the product or its category, for example 10%. The cashier may sell down to cost minus 10% without the Sell Below Cost permission. A lower price goes to **Ask a manager**.

- The product's limit replaces its category's, like the Discount Limit.
- Empty means no room: a price under cost needs a manager's approval.
- The cashier still never sees the cost. The refusal only says the price is too low.

See [Adding a product](https://vende.id/docs/produk-dan-harga/menambah-produk?lang=en) and [Discount limit](https://vende.id/docs/jualan/diskon-dan-barang-gratis?lang=en#discount-limits).

## The date of the note

A new note's date is always the moment of saving, except for people with the **Change Date** permission. When the cashier needs another date, save the note first, then use **Ask permission to change the date** on that note's page, or ask a manager who may record it.
